Beat The Prosecution- Fairfax, Virginia, Criminal Defense / DUI Lawyer
Welcome to Beat The Prosecution with Fairfax, Virginia criminal defense / DUI lawyer Jonathan Katz. Jon Katz believes in spreading the word of justice on this podcast, in court, and on his blog at https://katzjustice.com/blog, to regularly provide information and ideas for beating your prosecution. More information is available at https://KatzJustice.com and at (703)-383-1100.
Beat The Prosecution- Fairfax, Virginia, Criminal Defense / DUI Lawyer
Advocating for all sentient beings- Professor Justin Marceau
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
When Fairfax County, Virginia, criminal defense lawyer Jonathan Katz was leaving the subway station one day, an animal rights activist was welcoming people to sign a petition supporting proposed animal protection legislation in the District of Columbia. Already a vegetarian for primarily for the health of animals, Jon looked at the draft legislation, told the activist he would not sign a petition seeking to expand the overgrown criminalization system, and the activist did not seem to take Jon seriously.
It took decades for Jon to find animal rights lawyers who speak out against the drive among many animal rights activists to exert harsh criminal court treatment for those harming animals, while going to court for animal rights and animal rights activists (and cheering on alleged animal abusers to obtain justice in court). That is why this Beat the Prosecution episode interviews Denver University law professor Jusin Marceau, who is extensively on all fours with Jon against this animal rights carceral approach, and who points out the animal rights bumper sticker from years ago saying Abuse an Animal; Go to Jail. Take, for example, that the same prosecutors seeking a conviction and even jail against a person allegedly not calling a veterinarian or animal welfare authorities earlier in an animals' ailment progression (and other alleged offenses against animals), will the next day be prosecuting animal rights activists arrested for a host of reasons. Prosecution for such alleged animal neglect can have the deleterious result of companion humans not seeking proper health care for their companion animals in ill health resulting from delayed health care. Efforts to get certain animal abuse crimes classified as felonies can bring adverse immigration risks. Justin further believes that overcriminalization of alleged animal abuse enables police to simply add such enforcement and investigation to already-existing police overpatrolling and enforcement in neighborhoods where lower percentages of white people live.
This interview includes interesting talk about fully devoted animal rights activist Wayne Hsiung, a lawyer who engages in such actions as rescuing animals from factory farms, has gotten arrested, and defends himself in court. Justin is representing Wayne on a criminal appeal that Wayne has. Here is Justin's law review article with Wayne and Steffen Seitz on "Voluntary Prosecution and the Case of Animal Rescue". Here are transcripts of interviews arranged by Justin of jurors from a conservative region of Utah who acquitted Wayne of theft of two (or so) sick pigs, where, pro se, Wayne argued that the pigs had no net value to have qualified for theft, where the price to provide the pigs needed health care exceeded the value that the animal processing facility assigned to the pigs.
Here is an excerpt from Justin's essential book (for animal rights activists) Beyond Cages- Animal Law and Criminal Punishment. He has also co-authored the animal rights boo, Empirical Animal Law: Testing the Assumptions of a Movement, as well as Carceral Logics: Human Incarceration and Animal Captivity.
Lawyers who, like Jon Katz, support the work of Justin's Animal Activist Legal Defense Project can offer their professional and monetary assistance, respectively by emailing Justin at Justin.Marceau@du.edu (where he also welcomes knowing about defendants that his Project will be interested in assisting), and donating at the Give Now link box here.
This episode also is on YouTube and Apple Podcasts.
This podcast with Fairfax, Virginia criminal / DUI lawyer Jon Katz is playable on all devices at podcast.BeatTheProsecution.com. For more information, visit https://KatzJustice.com or contact us at info@KatzJustice.com, 703-383-1100 (calling), or 571-406-7268 (text).
If you like what you hear on our Beat the Prosecution podcast, please take a moment to post a review at our Apple podcasts page (with stars only, or else also with a comment) at https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/beat-the-prosecution/id1721413675
Hello, everybody. This is John Katz of Beat the Prosecution. I'm a criminal defense and DUI defense lawyer here in Fairfax, Northern Virginia. I am absolutely delighted to have today's guest. He is a law professor. He is an author. Justin Marceau, I guess pronounced just the way Marceau pronounces it. He wrote Beyond Cages and more. Why is he on? He is a law professor in Denver. He is an animal rights supporter. And he's one of the first people I have found after all these decades among animal rights supporters who say, stop with this push for more prosecution, more criminal laws to help the animals. That's something that alienates me from a bunch of the people in the animal rights movement. In fact, when I had my first job out of law school, which was with a corporate law firm representing mostly financial institutions and transportation companies back around 1990, I was coming out the Metro in downtown DC, and there were these two nice seeming animal rights activists asking to sign a petition to uh have some animal rights legislation. And I looked over the legislation. Most people sign petitions before even looking at what backs it up. And it has something about criminalizing animal uh uh mistreatment of animals. And I said, I'm not gonna support uh an expansion of the uh criminal justice system. And the woman looked at me as if I was crazy, so I just walked away and I didn't sign it. With that, I and and he's I was I've been entertaining Justin. I see his reactions. I asked Justin to introduce yourself and please include how did you come to becoming a lawyer and being interested in animal rights and like I opposing this whole thing of doing massive criminalization uh for part of doing the animal rights work.
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you. Thanks, John. Thanks for having me on. I'm I'm excited to be here. And uh as he mentioned, my name is Justin Marceau. I'm a law professor at the University of Denver, and uh I direct our animal law program. I teach various constitutional law courses in animal law, and I teach first-year criminal law. And I think of my yeah, my sort of areas of relevance to this conversation today in animal law as having kind of four four pockets. The first, which I think we'll talk about a bit and also go back to, is a critique and a caution when it comes to using the criminal system and the belief that criminal law would be uh a beneficial aspect of protecting animals. Uh, and that was uh quite controversial and continues to be controversial, though the the idea is, I'll tell you, John, I'm starting to take. It's starting, I'm starting to start to win some folks over. Um the second thing that uh I have done a lot of in animal law is is related to that. I said, well, if we're investing all this money, millions and millions of dollars in the field and human time and actual dollars in criminal prosecution, what about defense? Uh and I started the first in this country, and I believe in the world, uh, activist defense project for animal activists and climate activists, but we're focused primarily on anyone who is being charged for crimes relating to their free speech or organizing or association rights, or just generally breaking the law in a form of civil disobedience. Um I started a clinic and we now have four attorneys that uh work full-time defending activists. Um, the third thing I've done in animal law is look at ways to increase transparency and certainly to fight back against anti-transparency measures. So I was one of the lead lawyers in the challenges under the First Amendment to criminal statutes known as egg egg laws that criminalized um undercover investigations in factory farm settings. Uh, so did a lot of that work. And then finally, uh, and with my new book, teamed up with some social scientists, uh, a book that just came out this month called Empirical Animal Law. And really what I'm doing there is studying some of the assumptions of our movement. The subtitle is Testing the Assumptions of a Movement. So up until now, animal law and animal protection has generally been guided by intuition, and I think that's what got us into trouble with the criminal aspect and not by data, not by quantitative testing. Uh, so I've been focused on that. But yeah, that's me in a nutshell, John. So thanks for having me on.
SPEAKER_00What made you decide to go to law school and to become a law professor and to do the animal rights work, which may not be all in uh chronological order?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I've always been interested in the law. I think I've been interested in uh, you know, we're a highly legalistic society, and so even I grew up in Montana, even in younger years, I I had an admiration for people who understood how the system worked. I wasn't sure what the system was, but I was sure it involved a lot of law. Um, my dad was a union organizer and worked on the railroad, and I had just come to understand that there were large systems of power that that I didn't understand and that I would would like to better. Uh, I actually started a military academy and was planning to be a pilot, and I had sinus surgery and couldn't be a pilot anymore, so um change of career plans and and ended up uh moving on and and and sort of pursuing law after that. Um and then yeah, as a you know, becoming an animal lawyer was was a bit of a a fluke actually because I didn't know there was a thing and there barely was a thing. But I um I had planned to go into human rights law and was looking at working in The Hague, uh, and I knew uh I ultimately took a job doing death penalty work. But in my last semester of law school, there was an animal law class that was offered by an adjunct professor, and I have no idea. I just sort of saw a poster for it and thought, well, that seems interesting and maybe even whimsical. And so I signed up for it, and um, you know, that that really did change the trajectory for me. I th I it was just something I hadn't thought about, I hadn't thought about why animals have such a disadvantaged status in the law, why we take them for granted. Uh, and then my life sort of just slowly changed. Um, so yeah, I mean, those are I mean, becoming a law professor, I don't know. I was not one of those people that went to law school planning to be a law professor. Um, I like to spend a long time on projects, I like to dig in and stay in it. So eventually it seemed like a natural fit. But I I love the practice of law and continue to do it. Like I said, defending activists just argued in the California Court of Appeals a few months ago on behalf of uh one of our clients, Wayne Sheng. Um, so very much kept a foot in practice, but but have been interested in educating the next generation in the same way that I was brought into animal law.
SPEAKER_00Are you a vegan or vegetarian? And if so, at what point in your legal career, before your legal career, did you do that and why?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great question, John. I mean, I am a vegan. I do, I do, I don't eat animals because uh I spend a lot of my free time and all of almost all of my philanthropic dollars and energy um trying to help uh slow down these animal exploitation injuries. So I'm not working against myself. Um I don't judge people who who don't who do consume one thing or another or wear one thing or another, but I I don't, um and it's just it's just my choice. I I came to that after animal law. Um I grew up, my family had a ranch, uh homestead in Montana, um, and eating animals was was not just normal, it was you know, it was like family culture, religion, everything wrapped up all together. So very much part of my identity. Uh, but after the course, I I became vegetarian pretty quickly. And then it took it took a while, but uh maybe uh a couple of years, a few years before I became vegan, and now um, yeah, I've been vegan more than a decade and a half.
SPEAKER_00As I may have told you, I became a vegetarian uh three years after graduating from college when I was eating up and down the food chain after asking myself, how can I eat uh fellow mammals, cows, for instance, after working with human rights matters with Amnesty International, when Amnesty wasn't pushing as much for carceral stuff. Amnesty later on started talking about bring people to the same justice system that caused injustice to people. And then uh as a very overweight vegetarian, they exist. I uh tried raw veganism, which yes, I I lost a lot of weight rapidly, but was hungry all the time. I mean, I guess I could have eaten raw honey and raw milk, but I decided not to do that. Um, as an aside before I get in right into it, did you say it's possible to call yourself vegan if you wear a wool? I can't call myself vegan because I wear a wool sometimes and I don't like it.
SPEAKER_01I I mean I think you should call yourself a vegan. I mean, I there's a few there's a few levels to that question, John. But I mean, the first thing I would say is, you know, as somebody who's very involved in this field, you know, on the board of a couple of the big animal rights groups in the country, um even in my position, I I don't think that policing the term itself is a good use of time of time or energy. I'm sort of I'm much more interested in whether a person is concerned with animal suffering, concerned about the status of animals in the law than whether they have a leather belt or a wool jacket. Um so the first thing is just I don't I don't really do the policing. I'm not I'm not interested in, you know, how much um, you know, how pure. I'm not sort of purity policing. And that's true of honey too. I mean, technically it's not vegan, but I don't go around and say, hey, is there is there honey on your granola? Uh it's just not, it's just not an interest of mine. I mean, contrary to what people think about vegans, we actually don't like to talk about the, you know, it can be quite personal, it's emotional, it's it's it's sad to think about animal suffering. So I'm not um, you know, proselytizing anything in particular other than ending systemic and structural animal suffering on a large scale. Uh, and that's why I don't invest in it. But I still have products that have to think about what they are. I probably have wool jackets too, um, John, because um I've had suits that I still wear that, you know, I sort of consider them grandfathered in. Anything that uh came on before I was vegan, I mean, what am I gonna do? Just throw it out, just waste it, uh, donate it. So anything I buy now, I try not to buy animal products. But um, you know, none of us are perfect. We're driving in cars, we're going in products, we're using train lines that that you know, deforest. I mean, there's there's there's no there's no perfection. So I just live my life in a way where I try to minimize the amount of suffering I cause animals. Uh, I do do better on some things than on others, but yeah, when it's when I'm sitting at the store or at the restaurant, I try not to have an animal product. This jacket here, it's a great jacket. Uh, you know, you don't have to look like an animal activist to uh to be a vegan animal lawyer. Um, this is from Twillery. Twillery has uh you know an off-the-shelf set of suits that are all synthetic. Uh I think super great. I wear them to court all the time. They're very sharp. And uh, you know, like so. So now when I'm replacing my and they're not they're not very expensive. Um and my when I'm replacing a you know wool suit jacket or suit, I I I go from to a website like that.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. You mentioned Wayne Shung, H-S-I-U-N-G. Oh, I've been asking him over time to come onto the podcast. I don't know if he just doesn't receive my messages. We'll get it, we'll get it whatever. But uh yeah, right. We know he's not available today, but you did mention representing him. So what type of representation have you been doing of him? Because this is a lawyer who goes pro se so often. Let me tell everybody, if you haven't heard about him, look him up. Wayne Shung, uh, talk about a true believer, he'll go in and he'll rescue animals, uh, knowing that he's gonna be prosecuted and maybe even put in jail about it. And he even wrote once, at least once, about a time when uh one of his pretrial release conditions was not to have any contact with some of his closest friends because they were involved in the alleged action too. And people he
SPEAKER_01lived with.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's more of them were his
SPEAKER_01housemates. Yeah. No, I mean, yeah, I mean, Wayne is um, I mean, Wayne is one of those irreplaceable figures at this particular time, at this particular moment in animal protection movement history. Um, you know, he tells a story of being a kid who wasn't particularly popular and and was bullied, and he saw a lot of himself in the eyes of animals. And as he got older and older and came of age, um, he knew that what he wanted to do was devote
unknownhis
SPEAKER_01life to animal protection. Super skilled guy, very knowledgeable. Um I have co-authored an academic article with him. I mean, he's he's brilliant, uh, hardworking, intrepid, all the things. Um, and he's also just a fierce and and feared advocate. Um, so you know, we can talk about lots of different things he did, but one of the things he did in the 2018s is um he entered a facility in Utah that produces pigs for meat, and they had vowed to be phasing out certain forms of confinement. He was sure that they probably had not. He entered, confirmed that they had not, and then also found a couple of piglets, subsequently called that named Lily and Lizzie, who were in such bad shape that they were soon to die if they were not taken out. And he rescued them and he brought them to a sanctuary, and uh, you know, they they've been living out, and one of them is is still thriving. One of them, unfortunately, had to um be put down by a veterinarian with with a with a cancer, but just amazing lives. And the facility didn't even notice that Lily and Lindsay were missing because they have tens of thousands of pigs, um, and these two that were going to die anyway were did not register. But then the New York Times did a story on Wayne's investigation and showed uh exactly what he had accomplished and what he saw. And then the facility um pressed charges against Wayne. And that's kind of you know classic Wayne, right? I mean, he got away with a crime, then he put it in the New York Times, then he got prosecuted, and he couldn't have been happier about the prosecution. Um, and he won, right? And so was that the moment where he
SPEAKER_00said that that the the animals didn't have any value under criminal law if they were gonna die? Yeah, yeah,
SPEAKER_01that's right. Is that the one
SPEAKER_00he got acquitted from?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's exactly right. So he uh it was a it was a charge of uh essentially theft, and uh the argument was well, these animals had negative value to Smithfield Foods, and how could that be? Well, because the veterinary records proved they were very, very sick, and it was going to cost well over $100 to get the animals even back on a healthy track. Um, and their their value was only $40. So he said, Is it you know, I actually did you a favor. Uh the the net value that I took from you was a negative. Uh, and so you should owe me, not vice versa. And a jury in very red, very rural um Utah, um, that was extremely skeptical of this case. And you can look online if you if you um Google the University of Denver jury studies, uh, and my name, Justin Marceau, you can you can look at transcripts. I interviewed the jurors who acquitted Wayne, and it's a fascinating story. Uh, I mean, these jurors were not amused and were not happy. Then they came to figure out what was going on in this pig facility right near their homes, and they unanimously acquitted this guy. Um, and the prosecutor was, you know, to say he was upset is a is an understatement. But but he was, you know, the prosecutor didn't do himself any favors. There's a line, I don't know if you ever saw this, John, but there was a in the closing statement, the prosecutor said, Well, Mr. Shung thinks he's rescuing pigs. And he kind of like snortles to himself and chuckles. And then he says, Well, what if I go into the store and I see a dented can? Can I stick it in my pocket and rescue it? I'm just rescuing a dented can. And every juror hated the idea that he was willing to compare a dented can to a dying piglet. Excellent. They all talked about it, right? I mean, and so this is the sort of thing that Wayne does, and it propels, and there's a there's a problem of scale, but jurors who had no connection to animal protection unanimously thought he was innocent. Some of them have gone vegan, some of them are joining the boards of farm sanctuaries. It's a remarkable
SPEAKER_00jurors?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00From that conservative section of USA, Utah?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00My gosh. And uh so Wayne did not, I take it, win therefore at the whatever they call it in Utah, the motion for judgment acquittal or motion to dismiss uh phase that that the elements weren't sufficient to convict that it had to go to the jury to to win. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01that's right. So, what is the work
SPEAKER_00you've done for for Wayne?
SPEAKER_01Oh man, well, I mean, we do a lot of work for Wayne because he's a busy, he's a busy activist. But but most recently, uh Wayne did represent himself pro se well, most recently, I mean, we have some ongoing representation in a in the in a Beagle facility in Wisconsin, but um the case that I referenced is um out of uh Northern California, Sonoma, California, um, and Wayne was involved um with activists who went in and rescued birds um from two different farms, two different factory farms, one that was primarily ducks and one that was chickens. And uh it's a fascinating case because in one of the cases, the evidence is that he stood essentially on a soapbox across the street from the factory farm and gave a sermon-like thing, as he does. I mean, he's a he's a he's a minister, uh, and he sort of was just preaching about the value of animal rights and telling everyone to be safe and these sort
unknownof
SPEAKER_01things. And he was he was charged essentially as an aider and a better for encouraging the um the activists who were doing a lockdown and doing a rescue. Uh, and the other one, he was on site and he wasn't carrying out any birds, but he was sort of telling law enforcement that he believed what they were doing was legal and that sort of thing. Uh, he ended up being convicted. Judge did not allow a necessity defense to proceed. And we took the so and in California, you can have a felony conviction for conspiring to do a misdemeanor. So this is interesting because you were correct that there was this theft charge. And so his argument in Utah previously had been the pigs didn't have any value to this facility. They were very sick, they were dying. Well, prosecutors got smart, or you might say cynical, um, I might say just uh absurd. They didn't want to charge him with stealing the animals. So what they charged him with in Sonoma was trespass, which is a misdemeanor. Same as if they trespassed onto your lawn. Simple trespass. Um, and then they charged him with felony conspiracy to trespass at the two places. So the felonies they pursued were conspiring to misdemeanor trespass. Um, absurd. It's just a it's a it's a gross example of the way that we can overcharge in this country, as you're aware. But um anyway, he was convicted on all four counts. And we appealed those and um argued a number of things, and we got three of those four convictions overturned in the California Court of Appeals, um, essentially on the ground that he should have been able to put on a defense um showing why he thought what he was doing was uh lawful and justified under the law, given the conditions. And so that was the conviction was reversed. He begged the prosecutor to retry him because that's what he likes. Uh and the prosecutor declined. Uh, and so, you know, but he did he did serve 60 days in jail, um, which you know he wouldn't have um if if that if he had not if we had had these convictions overturned in advance. But yeah, it's it's it's that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_00Before we get to a bunch more that I want to get to, I think it may have been uh what is your animal law um project called?
SPEAKER_01It's it's a kind of a mouthful. It's A-A-L-D-P, Animal Activist Legal Defense Project. Um, but yeah, I mean essentially Activist Legal Defense Project.
SPEAKER_00And people will find the URL wire, the website.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's great. I
SPEAKER_00mean,
SPEAKER_01or they'll Google,
SPEAKER_00or they'll just Google if you if
SPEAKER_01you Google Justin Marceau or you Google Animal Activist Legal Defense Project, but yeah, I'm sorry, I'm not a very good marketer. Um but it's but but do, I mean, this is the thing. I mean, one of the things we do, we like to team up with defense lawyers or listeners, we like to team up with people who have done things. So we take cases all over the country. I mean, one of our, you know, we had a big one in New York that was a cow that wandered onto a sanctuary, like truly just wandered onto the sanctuary. And the New York Times covered this case. And they accused the this nice woman of stealing the cow, and then they raided her sanctuary and stole the cow and slaughtered it, and then it became this kind of big um right versus left in rural New York. Uh, and we had the charge thrown out. We had the police um eventually sort of reprimanded by the judge for misconduct. It turned out that the police who are leading this investigation were the brother-in-law. I mean, there's all kinds of things that that can of the cow owner. Um, so we're doing cases all over the country for anyone that is trying to help animals and ends up getting ensnared in the criminal system.
SPEAKER_00Well, I want to talk to you about that. It was probably from your uh from your project that I got a call around a year ago, uh more or less, about whether I'd be available. I don't know who spoke to me.
SPEAKER_01Certainly could have been, yeah.
SPEAKER_00But I'm available. And I forget the name of the the law professor at your uh uh law school. I think I told you I met at the uh the vegan uh the vegan advocacy uh event they had in Alexandria, Virginia, around 2022 or 2023. And that's where I met Miyoko Shinner and talk about uh talk about a ball of energetic fire, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00And talk about someone who who got her her First Amendment right uh defended, and I think vindicated, if not mistaken, with the right and uh to to be able to call her products uh, I don't know, cream or whatever, even though they had no milk in them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, no. I mean, she she boldly did that work and was willing to take that fight on and was assisted by the Animal Legal Defense Fund. No, you're absolutely right. I mean, and she's incredible, thankful for what she did.
SPEAKER_00Okay, you mentioned uh ALDEF then, Animal Legal Defense Fund. To what extent is ALDEF, HSUS, Humane Society of the U.S., PETA on the right side or wrong side about your anti-carceral views and your strong First Amendment views? Because if I'm not mistaken, wasn't ALDEF spearheaded in part by Roger Galvin, who I met uh back in the day in the early 1990s, who was that uh Montgomery County, Maryland prosecutor uh who became interested in the animal rights movement when he was prosecuting this uh uh thing about the uh the the monkey experimentation, I guess at one of the labs of Montgomery County, Maryland, outside of D.C.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think Silver Springs monkey, maybe that's right. Yeah, I mean, it's a great question, John. And I'm always, just as I I don't like to judge people wherever they are on their vegan animal journey, I don't like to uh talk disparagingly of the allies too much. But but yeah, I mean, if you've read Beyond Cages, I mean you know a bit about my views. I I think that the motto for the movement um for for more than a decade, and certainly the best-selling t-shirt and bumper sticker was abuse an animal, go to jail. And not unlike you, uh I came into this movement because I cared about animals. And when the first animal law conference I went to, I remember so clearly and so viscerally sitting there. And, you know, I had had a client executed. I had like I had lived through the criminal justice system, and here were these people up on stage talking about how we needed mandatory minimums, we needed abuse registries, we needed to update our laws so that there were higher maximum penalties. Um, you know, if we could, we should be charging more juveniles as adults. Um, we should be helping with more immigration uh enforcement. And I thought I was gonna lose my lunch. I was like, what is happening here? Like, you know, how do you think that a sentence of 10 years instead of five years is gonna be twice as much protection for the animal? And we started investing in this idea that, you know, locking people up was tantamount to helping animals. And somehow, because I think we had lost so much, I don't know Roger Gow, and I'd love to uh I mean if you're still in contact with him, or he's still around, um, have that association. I don't know if he's
SPEAKER_00still around.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't know. But you know, I I think that these I think that the motivation didn't come from malice, it came from the same place that um it came from two things. One, that advocates for animals were just losing everywhere they uh we weren't getting any wins. And so uh if you want to get a win, which the public wants winners, right? They don't want to be on the losing team all the time, um, looking to criminal prosecution is always a is always a good choice because I mean that's something police officers will be like, oh yeah, we probably should be abusing those people more. Oh yes, we need more of that, says the says the district attorney. So it was it was partly that, and it was also partly born of, I think, a naivete about how the criminal justice system would work in this country. Um, I think of it as kind of like reverse NIMBYism, right? I mean, most animal people are actually quite empathetic, they're quite um compassionate. They they usually register higher on those metrics psychologically. Um, and NIMBYism, this idea of not in my backyard, you say, well, I don't want, I think that we need more mental health hospitals or we need more high schools or whatever it might be, just not next to me, right? We need more halfway houses. And this is kind of the opposite, which is that animal advocates often say, like, I know prison is terrible, it's a racist, broken, ineffective system, but when it comes to animals, we really need a lot of it. Um, and so it's it's a jarring story and one that um, yeah, I mean, just very few people would stand up and challenge. And so I would ask questions at these conferences, but people would kind of sneer and be like, oh, you know, what is he trying to do? Just make a make a scene. And so that's why I sat down sometime, you know, in 2016, 2015 to start writing Beyond Cages, because I wanted to have a book-length treatment of the problems that I saw just as a normative matter, just as a sort of moral and ethical matter, with the animal law movement investing heavily in in a tough and cry tough on crime approach. Uh and now, you know, in newer works, I have added some empirical studies to that. Uh, I've talked about some of the concrete failures that have emerged. But yeah, I mean, to me, it's it's a it's a nasty example of the movement just miscalculating, right?
SPEAKER_00Okay. So to what extent is there a section of the animal rights movement that is willing to also trample on free expression rights in the name of animal rights?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think it's I think the the animal protection movement is doing better on that, um, especially post um around 2012, because you know, industry between 2010 and 200, I think, 15, 24 states introduced these laws called ag gag laws that I mentioned that made it a crime to do undercover investigations only in agricultural facilities. And the movement realized that if they allied themselves with kind of anti-speech uh type norms, they were going to be on the wrong side of these laws and the wrong side of history. So for the most part, when I see people in animal protection now, I think that they are pretty progressive, pretty, they have a pretty um free speech um absolutist approach. I will say that, you know, there are there are exceptions and there are some deviations. I mean, you you come across things where people want to not allow certain types of expression or certain types of things. Um, and I consider myself basically a free speech absolutist. The the exception would be uh I don't think that uh, you know, as any good free speech lawyer knows, there's there's conduct versus speech. I don't think that harming animals is a form of speech. And I don't think using the fruits of such um, you know, activities is. Now, the movement itself had some rather shameful litigation around free speech in the US versus Stevens, the Supreme Court about crush videos. I mean, that was rather reprehensible. I haven't thought about that for a little while, but you know, they they essentially wanted to say that um because people were engaged in uh and you know, this sort of pornography where you abuse animals, they wanted new criminal laws and they wanted those criminal laws to target the production of videos. Uh fortunately, the Supreme Court was willing to recognize that the statute was incredibly overbroad, as many of these things, when you try to just sweep up and solve a social problem by writing a broad statute, this statute would have ended up criminalizing all kinds of things, including periodicals, right? Like hunting magazines and the like. So the court, the court pushed back, but that's an example where if the animal protection movement thinks that there is a just like the petition you were asked to sign, if they think there is a law that is pro-animal, everything else kind of falls away and they get they get these blinders on. Um, I think they're getting better about that in the in the free speech realm, and I think they're getting more strategic. Uh ALDF just you know elected a new um uh executive director, Caitlin Hawks, who was a you know prized litigator at PETA, uh a big law lawyer. I think she has really strong commitment to free speech. Uh, and so I'm so I'm you know, and I think PETA has always had a pretty strong commitment to free speech because they're they're out there on the margins doing things and frequently having activists charged. But yeah, I mean, cases like Stevens come to the court and they all line up as amicus or they all start saying, this is what we need. Um so I think it's, you know, I mean, it's important for people who care about animals to not set aside their their priors, not think about, oh, well, animals and we don't need free speech, and animals, oh, and we should have more incarceration. And that's what I always tell people when they're coming into law school. Like, don't forget who you are as a person. And the same is true as an animal advocate, right? I mean, we can still be have a recognition that the criminal system, for example, is very good at having bad guys, right? I mean, you know very well from your work, uh, what the criminal law is good at is identifying the villain. And you can make a headline about a villain and you can tell a story about a villain, and it can be compelling. But what it's very bad about is solving a social problem, right? Like coming out of that and saying, oh, we're gonna we're gonna end this or we're gonna do it with this. Like it's terrible at that. Uh, and so this investment in making bad guys, getting them on the front page of the paper, uh, is just terrible policy, it's terrible spending, and it's the kind of investment that actually works against our long-term interests. Because now I see that in my own clinic, right? The very resources that we're building up, the infrastructure we're giving to prosecutors with more discretion and more power, um, they always turn and use that against activists. And that's the thing I think that people forget when they're in marginalized groups is that if you empower the prosecutors, they're gonna not use that just in the situation you want. They're gonna turn around and use that same power against these sort of more marginalized, um, you know, non-status quo groups.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so you mentioned your clinic. What does what's the name of your clinic and what does your clinic do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it the clinic is the Animal Activist Legal Defense Project, and uh we represent activists all over the country that that have cases. I mean, they could be free speech challenges, they could be um, you know, just prosecutions for pamphleting when they when when you know sometimes they get we get we get we get the full gamut. And then there are cases where you know the activist has clearly done something like we were talking about with Wayne, you know, taking taking animals outside of a facility, those sort of things. Um so we take all those cases and we bring some um preemptive uh civil cases. So in case of your interest in the sort of First Amendment realm, perhaps we have a pending challenge. With PETA challenging, we we don't believe that um two-party recording statutes are constitutional. Uh, and so we have been challenging, and we're challenging one in Massachusetts, which is the most restrictive in the country at the moment. Um, it impedes the ability to do investigations. So you could do a video of someone abusing an animal in a slaughterhouse or in a zoo or something, but you can't have the audio. And what that enables is um management and the system and the structures to lose accountability. You could get that one person who's the I mean you can get, but you can't hear them say, I was told to do this by my boss or whatever, right? And so we're challenging those kind of statutes. But it's it's that kind of work. It's free speech and activist defense.
SPEAKER_00Virginia's a one-party uh consent paradise for that.
SPEAKER_01All right, all right. Well, John, come on. Let's let's let's see what I
SPEAKER_00want an assault. I want an assault trial because my client was secretly recording his girlfriend who who claimed that he assaulted her after she told him when he came home that she was breaking up with him. So I just strung her along during cross-examination about that. And then I played the tape and I said, uh, isn't this tape accurate? Showing that my client came home and broke up with you. Wonderful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean, exactly. I mean, and in in instances of uh interpersonal violence, it's it's really quite important, right? And you have some of these recording laws, people don't think about the implications, right? I mean, imagine if you were just recording a beautiful bird in Boston and and you happened from the street to catch some other conversations. The prosecutor might not prosecute you, but that's just uh that's just prosecutorial discretion, that's just no bless oblige. They're not required to because you did capture an audio recording of a conversation and you didn't get permission for it. So they're incredibly broad and um and and we think quite quite dangerous.
SPEAKER_00What type of immigration enforcement have some of the animal rights folks been seeking?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great question. So um in the late 2010s uh, I mean, these as you probably know, a lot of immigration cases end up under seal in one form or another. So it's it's quite hard. And and after Beyond Cages, um, groups stopped wanting to cooperate with me and tell me some of the things they were filing. So um my my records are are uh are a little limited. But but uh but a great example is a case um of a father of two who was um at a dog fight, reprehensible, terrible, and they sought to deport this person. ICE did. And um asked animal lawyers if they would join the case and tell the immigration court as interveners or as anarchists that um there should be no exception, like that animal crime should be treated as a crime of moral turpitude, such as crazy. Sorry?
SPEAKER_00Crazy,
SPEAKER_01yeah, so that so that the person is automatically removable. And when pressed on this, or it's still up on the website, when pressed on this, the animal lawyers said, yeah, but you know, we were just trying to convince the court that the animals were persons. And if you know, if you did this to a person, um and so it's this kind of race to the bottom mentality where they say, Yeah, like that we should do this. And you know, similarly, they've they sought to have juveniles uh put in adult prison. The kid was already convicted. They didn't doubt that the animal was safe, they didn't doubt that the kid was being held accountable. They filed briefs just saying, what we want here is to show how important animal abuse is to have a kid punished as an adult. I mean, it's it's kind of mind-boggling, but it shows you where the logic, the carceral logic will get you. Um, because if you say what you're doing is for a dog, you don't care that a 16-year-old is going to end up in a prison cell with a 50-year-old man. Uh, I mean, it's it's absolutely shocking, I think.
SPEAKER_00I have had one client who brought his wife's dog to uh the vet, and the dog was, you know, filled with maggots, and then the vets called in the uh the animal control people, and my guy got prosecuted. We got him a uh great result to get an ultimate dismissal, but nonetheless, uh that was the trajectory there. And I had another client who called up animal control because her dog was very sick, and uh the uh tables were turned on her uh alleging that she hadn't gotten uh veterinary care um early enough. And uh uh I got that one uh uh a great result. Uh but it but isn't this true that uh isn't this one of your themes, right? That making things so carceral uh could backfire for people not to go ahead and report things, uh you know, it kind of kind of like uh like the Good Samaritan laws with uh with drugs, the people might not not report things to the cops so they don't get prosecuted themselves.
SPEAKER_01That's exactly right. No, I
SPEAKER_00mean
SPEAKER_01it might not
SPEAKER_00take someone to the van.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we see we see this happening, actually. I mean, there are there are cases, I talk about this in the book, Carceral Logics, where um I mean, if we step back, I mean the the examples you gave are so perfect because uh what they show is that quite often the best response is not an arrest. The best response is not a prosecutor, it might be a bag of food, it might be some pet medical insurance, it might be, you know, a handout. Like it's not it's not a prosecution. And the and you know, one thing that your listeners should know is that every empirical piece of data that I've ever seen from every state that tracks animal crime, the vast majority of animal crimes, often in the neighborhood of 60% to two-thirds, are neglect, which is essentially a crime of poverty, right? They didn't they didn't get enough veterinary care, they didn't do this. But then we pass these crazy felony laws, just like we do, sort of like creating a scare around serial killers, so that we can, and then the law is used against the people who are facing neglect, right? You know how it works. The prosecutor has a 10-year maximum. Uh, they can bring that against somebody who didn't feed their dog well, just as much as they could bring it against somebody who choked their dog. Uh and the vast majority of the cases are the are the are the neglect. And you know, the other thing to realize about these cases is um people think that they're not being tough on crime because a lot of what the animal groups are post-beyond cages pushing are a little bit more moderate reforms, or they sound like that, like mandatory reporting laws or you know, uh higher fees and restitution. Well, what does a mandatory reporting law do, right? So a mandatory reporting law expands who has to tell people that they've heard that there's animals to maybe social workers, to veterinarians. Who could be opposed to that, right? Like, well, what we but you have to think about what you're doing. You're just feeding cases into the criminal system. So there's a case in Texas that I read about where a poor woman who loved her dog, her dog was limping, and she brought him into the veterinarian, and then the veterinarian said, you know, this breed frequently gets madding, he has terrible matting under here, and it's getting infected. And she said, Okay, can you fix it? And the cost was exorbitant and she couldn't afford it. And so she, you know, she he did a couple trims, but he said, You know, I don't think this is gonna help. She brought the dog home, and the dog couldn't was not healing, and she couldn't afford it. And so, what does she do? She surrenders the dog to a shelter. She is so torn up about this. She is crying, she's upset, everyone agrees. She wanted the dog, she couldn't afford the dog. She surrenders the dog. And you know what happened? The state veterinarian at this facility where she surrendered the dog reported her for felony neglect because the dog had this terrible wound. And all she wanted to do was have a dog and take care of him. And she ended up getting arrested, she ended up being detained for a couple of months facing charges, and uh, then she ended up being turned over to us for deportation. So you could imagine what the people in her neighborhood think about surrendering a dog or saying, hey, I'm not sure I'm getting the right care for this dog. You think they're gonna go to the shelter next time? You think that that person's lawyer is going to tell people, well, you better go to the shelter and surrender it. No, right? I mean, it's exactly the opposite. And we're seeing that kind of thing play out all the time. I mean, that's the thing. It's not, it's not just that the carceral animal law has the same race effects, and it does. It's very disparate racial and class outcomes. Um, people under $50,000 make less than $50,000 seem to be the only ones who know people charged with animal abuse. Um, and the racial disparities are exactly like what we just we have seen described in Michelle Alexander's The New Jim Crow. But it's not just that the human costs are high. Like animals do suffer from lack of reporting, um, from lack of investment and resources and legislation that could actually help them. So it's it's it's truly a harm to the animals.
SPEAKER_00So, what happened to this with the deportation process?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, it's great, it's a great thing. I mean, I've actually reached out to her lawyer because I wrote about her case in one of my books. And um, I I'm I'm not sure. I mean, they've they've kind of they've kind of I mean, we know for sure that she was released from uh a city jail into an ICE facility. And um people have not talked about it, but I mean, she would have been there in this this last uh era of you know the hardest, harshest approach we've had to immigration in my lifetime. And so my my guess is that uh she was removed from the country.
SPEAKER_00To what extent is animal cruelty enforcement uh harming um uh uh you know uh causing racial issues any more than the criminal justice system at large? And for those of you who are wondering how do I uh think that, well, we have prosecutors with prosecutorial discretion and judges with uh sentencing and other discretion, so race is gonna come in there uh automatically, and then you have uh uh uh a system that's that's uh often racist in effect. And of course, there are there are a bunch of people who just say that the American legal system is racist uh from the get-go. And but uh to what extent uh is there anything separate about that, about about the animal rights activists and how that affects uh uh people uh who are not white?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean I I could give you know a lot of examples. I'll give a couple of of of numbers to you, but it's it's a it's a really sort of chilling and I think should give us all pause. You know, probably when you were starting your criminal defense career, I won't make any assumptions. But if the police wanted to get into an apartment or they wanted to get in someplace, one of the things they would use, and that I I teach some cases that do this in state court, is they'd say, ah, I think I smell burnt marijuana. That's right. Uh and then that's I got my probable cause. Well, um, sadly, we already know which neighborhoods in this country are more policed and over policed and where there are the highest rates of surveillance. Um if you think something is going wrong, and now if you hear a dog barking, you might be able to say, Wow, like I sometimes say that the barking dog is the new burnt marijuana. You say, Oh, I think there might be some animal harm going on there. I think I think there may be a neglected dog. I got to get in there. Um, and so, you know, animal abuse is something we should care a lot about. I mean, it is, I mean, that to be clear, I am I am in favor of animal rights. I consider myself an animal liberationist. I just think that the approach that is committed to um criminal law is is deeply flawed. As your question assumes, like there is there is a massive racial set of racial disparities in the criminal system generally. And when I wrote Beyond Cages, I sort of took for granted that the average animal reader would read the book and say, Yeah, that probably happens in animal law too. And instead, John, one of the big pieces of feedback I got was, well, you're just assuming, but we know that that wouldn't happen in animal law. And that was shocking to me as a criminal person because I was like, You think it's a different system? Like you think that the system somehow got really good when we were just talking about this type of crime? But everyone, like every talk I would Give people, but you don't have any data. Like you're just assuming it's bad for them. Well, it's the same prosecutor. What do you think is but so one of the things that we did in my newest book, Empirical Animal Law, that just came out, is comprehensively study some of the deterrence that doesn't exist in any state because the higher criminal penalties do not correlate with less animal cruelty. So you're not getting that payoff. And then we tried to look at the racial disparities. And I'll just tell you, they're shockingly bad. So I mentioned Michelle Alexander's book. She wrote a book that was that was really controversial, but also very powerful in 2010 called The New Jim Crow. And the basic thesis was that racially neutral laws in modern America can have the effect of still creating a racial caste system or racial subordination because they are applied in such disparate ways against persons of color. And so her classic examples, what she calls New Jim Crow laws, are things like vagrancy laws and drug laws and bad check laws and these kinds of things, because the number of arrests, according to national data, and the number of charges for those types of crimes are much higher for persons who are black than the black persons are prevalent in the population. In other words, black persons are greatly overrepresented in those crimes. Now that doesn't prove that they aren't committing those crimes more frequently, right? We don't know that. Like the denominator is always a hard thing in criminal studies. But what she says is when you've got a system that's putting, you know, this, like twice as many black persons under arrest or under charge for a crime than they are present in the population, that law is working in a racist way. Well, what one of the crimes that she could have easily used, and what we show in the new book is animal crime sits right in the middle of those. It's not the highest or the lowest in the categories she's clear clocking, but it's right there. So when we're talking about vagrancy and public drunkenness and disorder and all these things, animal crime has disproportionate impacts on marginalized persons at those same levels. And so it's really shocking, right? You don't have to accept that the entire criminal system is racist or broken if you don't want to. But what you can know is that if you think there is a problem with disparate outcomes for persons of color at any level, animal crime fits uncomfortably close to the crimes that have been called out as the worst of the worst offenders, right? When most people say, yeah, yeah, I think there's a race problem in criminal law, they think drug crime. They aren't thinking animal crime. And so what we show is actually animal crime sits really close in terms of the racial disparities. So it's a it's a pretty jarring finding.
SPEAKER_00And what animal crimes are you talking about beyond what we've just talked about? Does this include dog fighting, cog fighting, uh, anything that's going on at uh uh animal processing plants?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, that's a great. So so here's the thing. I mean, what we have is is it's coded at a high level, like national, you know, FBI data and those kind of things. So what we would know is that it is is animal, um a crime charge is animal cruelty or neglect. Those are those are usually in the same statutory code provision. Um but the important thing to realize is that, uh, and so we don't have we don't have a lot of granular data below that and beneath that. But your question actually is quite savvy because we the the the granular data that we have from individual states shows that almost never is it the sort of like crush video or the you know the worst of the worst type of anything. That's just not very common among animal harm. Um, not just by volume, right? We know billions of animals are being killed in industrial settings, and we're talking about you know, hundreds or dozens that are probably abused or killed in sort of the pet space. But um, not just that, but it is it's what we know is that the animals that are that are suffering the most don't have recourse to prosecution. So there's never corporate prosecutions. Um it's it's an interesting thing, right? We have elected district attorneys, they don't want to go after the factory farm. And the factory farm is very happy to throw the low-level worker, often undocumented, under the bus. Uh, it's the sort of old Stanford prison experiment, right? The idea of bad apples versus a bad barrel. Every time an allegation of abuse and misconduct happens at one of these large facilities, what happens is the industry points the finger at the low-level minimum wage worker and says, Yeah, yeah, he should be deported and we think he should go to prison, and we've never seen anything like it. We'll never see anything like that again. Um, and then they're not culpable, right? Um, and what we say is like, no, you gotta go after the corporation, right? I mean, they had like this person was like there's corporate liability here, but they never do. It never happens. Um and the other thing that your question raises, and one of the things we studied is actually maybe to me the most chilling thing that I've learned about carceral animal law, which is that the movement, because of the push to say abuse an animal, go to jail, has actually miseducated the public, and in particular the animal rights followers, about what matters. And so we did these studies of people and what they thought uh should be the, you know, what we should be doing in animal law, like what's the most important thing in animal law, or what are the most important kinds of cases? Sort of public surveys. And it turns out there's a there's a wide range of opinion, and people have different opinions, that's fine. Um, but what we learned is that people who are engaged with the animal movement, so we have lots of demographic data, race, economics, education, all kinds of things we control for. But the variable that is most interesting is a person who's receiving mailers or otherwise considers themselves in connection with one or more animal protection groups, those people are the most carceral, right? They think that the best thing we can do for animals is have more prosecutions, more crimes, and more prosecutions. It's exactly what the petition you were signing. And they're not more punitive in general, right? So when you talk to them about, like when you talk about to the most animal rights-oriented person, they're not more punitive in general, they're slightly less, not in a statistically secure. But when you think of talk to them about what should be our priority, it's always lock them up type thinking. And that guess what? They don't know where most animal abuse is occurring. You say, like, where do you think most animals are harmed? They think it's next door at the neighbors. They think the neighbor is probably abusing puppies, and they don't think about the factory farm. They don't think about the various industries that are harming animals. So our movement, right, has probably miseducated a whole generation of people who care about animals into thinking that what they need to do is donate to more prosecution. And that's the part that really I think is chilling is that you know these slogans, abuse an animal, go to jail, they aren't just rhetoric, right? I mean, the public is deferring to us. We we naturally like animals. And so if the animal experts are telling us that the most important thing is we can do is sign a petition to have longer sentences or more crimes, they think that's probably what we should be doing, right? They're the experts. So, I mean, I think that part is just terrifying.
SPEAKER_00You're talking to the converted. So, with three, two minutes left to the show that's called Beat the Prosecution. What do you want to share with us, criminal defense lawyers and criminal defendants, about things we should do to beat the prosecution, to win in justice in criminal court?
SPEAKER_01Oh, what a great question. I mean, I I think that, you know, using the First Amendment, all the constitutional rights and and bringing those up as frequently as you can is the key. But I also want you to um just reach out, right? I'm here, Justin Marsau at the University of Denver. If you see a case where we could help with uh with an activist in particular being prosecuted or something interesting where there's some overlap in animals, let us know. I mean, we have served as expert witnesses in cases where a person is being prosecuted for animal abuse, not because we think animal abuse is good, but because we think that that person, we have expertise and we can talk about how that person should not be convicted and how that's not going to be a good outcome. So if there's an animal that's involved, um, we like to see the prosecution getting beat. And if that means trying an activist, that means them getting an acquittal. And if it means uh a person being charged with animal abuse, we also don't think that person should probably be getting convicted either.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. So uh what is the contact place for a person to use to let you or your organization? Yeah, I
SPEAKER_01mean the best email, I mean, email me, Marceau is how it spells, but J Marceau, J Marceau at law.du.edu. Um, I that's my direct email, uh my university email. I respond to that. And uh if you Google Justin Marceau, you'll come to the uh uh Animal Law Program and Activist Defense website. I'll you can also find some of my my team there. But uh thanks so much, John, and thanks for uh thanks for your show.
SPEAKER_00Thanks. And once again, Marceau is spelled M-A-R-C-E-A-O. If you are an animal. That's what I get for not reading it as I'm going along. M-A-R-C-E-A-U. And if you're an animal rights person, read his book, Beyond Cages, and look up on Amazon and elsewhere what uh Justin's other books are. Justin, is there anything you would like to say that you did not get a chance to say yet, or anything you would like to emphasize you've not already emphasized, including does your organization accept donations, or do you recommend giving donations to anywhere else?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I, you know, I appreciate the time. I mean, we we do. We're uh we're a fully donation-run facility, and we're we're we train students to go out and be defense lawyers and hopefully, even if they're not doing full-time defense work, to take on activist cases. I mean, that's that's the purpose. The goal of the clinic is to keep activists out of jail, educate law students who are going to defend activists in the future, and and sort of generate conversation and media coverage about these cases and hopefully shame the prosecution. So always always willing to take donations, always willing to help in co-counsel, and and we're always looking for local counsel. So one of the things we're trying to do is build out a local council network across the country. So one of the things I was excited about is being on this show. And if if you're willing to help be a local counsel wherever you are and listening to this, including in Virginia, John, um there's very it's very likely we're gonna end up having a case there sometime or another, and and uh we would love to team up. So maybe check out. Excellent.
SPEAKER_00So I'm I'm already uh I'm already on board there. So everybody, if you're a lawyer and you're a believer in what uh Just is saying, let them know that you're interested. And Justin, is there a donation link or does someone just send the send a check over to the law school and say that it's your marketing? There probably is
SPEAKER_01a donation link on the website. I'm sorry I'm bad at this, but but yeah, I mean it's it's uh you know, if you email me, I will I will find a way to do it. And I I mean we're we're we're very grateful. Uh and the activists, I can tell you it it it changes it changes their their life to have a lawyer who's sort of understands, understands this cause. So appreciate you.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. Well, I'm happy I got a chance to get that word out to uh get people to be on board with with helping out as lawyers for the activists and also about where to send the donations. Everybody you've heard from Justin Marceau, again, correctly spelling his name, M-A-R-C-E-A-U, a law professor at Denver Law School. Thank you so much. This is John Katz. I'm a criminal defense and DUI defense lawyer here in Fairfax, Northern Virginia. This is beat the prosecution because there is no other way. Stand by, Justin.